Our Underwriters

Tohickon Settlement Services works with three companies to underwrite our title insurance policies, not just one. We believe strongly that teaming with more than one underwriter—two national companies and the other a local company specializing in PA and NJ—allows us to offer our clients the highest rated title insurance available. Our multiple associations also expose our agents to a greater network of professionals to call upon when they need answers relating to intricate issues affecting title. Through these valuable alignments, we have the ability to work through almost any obstacle: a key reason why Tohickon has adopted a “no problem is insurmountable” approach.

Conestoga Title Insurance Company

Conestoga, based in Lancaster, PA, has expanded its footprint over the years and is now licensed to issue title insurance in 13 states and the District of Columbia. The company provides independent agents such as Tohickon with superior underwriting support and is one of the most trusted names in the title insurance industry.

Even more significant for our clients, Conestoga is the only underwriter approved in Pennsylvania to file its own rates for policies over $1 million—and that can mean substantial savings on a title insurance policy.

Here’s how it works: Conestoga holds a “reinsurance treaty” with a large national title insurance underwriter. Through this arrangement, the premium for a policy on over $1 million comes to as much as 20 percent less than the TIRBOP (Title Insurance Ratings Bureau of Pennsylvania) rate.

In actual practice, the greater the policy amount, the higher the discount. Please call 215.794.0700 or email info@tohickon.browndogstage.com for a fast, accurate quote: Each policy is quoted individually by Conestoga and turned around within minutes.

Conestoga was established in 1973 and is owned by Donegal Insurance Group, which has written over $350 million in property and casualty insurance.

Fidelity National Title Insurance Company

FNTIC can trace its origins back 150 years to 1848 and C.V. Gillespie, a notary public and searcher of records in San Francisco who founded Western Title Insurance Company (now Fidelity National Title Insurance Company of California) just prior to the California Gold Rush.

In 1906, employees of Western Title Insurance and their wives were credited with saving the title plant and other valuable records of the company from the San Francisco earthquake and fire. With such intrepid beginnings, FNTIC takes pride in its rich history of serving customers with accuracy and efficiency—and unequalled financial strength to back every title insurance policy.

Fidelity provides title insurance policies to Tohickon customers in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

FNTIC is part of Fidelity National Title Group, itself a member of the Fidelity National Financial family of companies and the nation’s largest group of title companies and title insurance underwriters. Collectively they issue more title insurance policies than any other title company in the United States.


Stewart is a global real estate services company, offering products and services through its network of Stewart Trusted Providers™ and family of companies. From residential and commercial title insurance to specialized offerings for the mortgage industry, Stewart delivers the comprehensive service, deep expertise and solutions customers need for any real estate transaction. Financial strength and exceptional service are the roots of its 126 years in business and the foundation for the peace of mind it provides to customers.

Stewart Title Company began in Galveston, Texas, in 1893 when Maco Stewart, a young Galveston attorney and the son of eminent jurist and legislator William H. Stewart, purchased the Gulf City Abstract Company. Maco, along with his brothers Minor and Clegg and brother-in-law W.C. Morris, would all play major roles in the company’s development. In 2012, nearly 120 years after it launched, Forbes recognized Stewart as one of its Top 100 Most Trustworthy Companies in America, based on an independent audit of over 8,000 companies listed on U.S. stock exchanges.

As industry leaders, Stewart is constantly evolving in order to deliver the expertise, tools and resources its partners and associates need to conduct business more efficiently. Its digital solutions, educational resources and unmatched expertise deliver a better customer experience for all.

WFG National Title Insurance Company

Portland, Oregon-based WFG National Title Insurance Company is a national provider of premium real estate and mortgage-related services. The fastest growing national title underwriter, WFG National Title also delivers a wide variety of residential and commercial mortgage lender services, including default and real estate-owned transactions.

Built around the directive to “communicate, collaborate, coexist,” WFG National Title has committed to applying a new philosophy to the traditional mortgage and real estate industry, working to meet the changing needs of its clients, agents and associates.

WFG National Title has been given a Financial Stability Rating of A’ (A prime) by Demotech Inc. Formerly known as TransUnion National Title Insurance Company, it is one of several established businesses in the title and real estate settlement services industry that have been acquired by Williston Financial Group Company, which was formed in late 2009.

Contact Us

Tohickon Settlement Services
6464 Lower York Road
Suite B
New Hope PA 18938

And now in Center City

One Liberty Place
1650 Market Street, Suite 3600
Philadelphia, PA 19103

And in New Jersey

372 Route 18
East Brunswick, NJ  08816

How can we help?